10 Supplements That Do Not Work as Advertised
By Maria Trimarchi, How Stuff Works, 21 July 2014.
By Maria Trimarchi, How Stuff Works, 21 July 2014.
Fish oil is one of the most common supplements taken in the U.S., but is it just snake oil in disguise? Something's fishy in the world of supplement marketing, and it's difficult to know if the benefits and health claims on the packaging are for real or just false advertising.
The sales of supplements are bolstered by the promise of improved health and longevity, but many of
those claims aren't substantiated.
Dietary supplements are popular in the U.S., and the number of Americans trying to insure their path to wellness is well-paved with nutrients (whether we're eating a balanced diet or not) is on the rise. As many as 69 percent of Americans take a daily dietary supplement, a percentage that's risen from 64 percent in 2008 (and only about 50 percent in 2000). That makes this really big business; more than US$20 billion is spent annually on multivitamins or other dietary supplements (whether it's capsules, pills, tablets or liquid) [source: Walsh, Morrison].
But what, exactly, are we getting for our billions? The majority of people taking a supplement do so because they believe these vitamins, minerals and herbs will cure colds, build muscles, improve memory and generally benefit their health and lifespan. As it turns out, many don't live up to their claims. In fact, in some instances you might just be healthier without them.
10. Echinacea Versus the Common Cold
If you’ve never heard someone singing the praises of echinacea as a cold remedy, you might be the only one.
Echinacea is not a new treatment; more than 400 years ago, Native Americans were using it to treat infections and for other medicinal needs. In fact, the flower was officially listed in the U.S. Pharmacopeia and National Formulary (USP-NF) in the first half of the 20th century, but its popularity and usage declined with the introduction of antibiotics.
Today echinacea is having a revival of sorts, and the herbal supplement is commonly taken to prevent the onset of or reduce the symptoms of the common cold and other upper respiratory tract infections. While some swear by the healing power of echinacea, at least if started as the first symptoms appear, scientists can't agree - but, neither can they disagree. Echinacea may help the body decrease inflammation by perking up your immune system, and if that's the case it may also ease cold symptoms. Although it may not work that way at all. Clear as mud?
A 2007 study found that echinacea supplements did reduce the duration of the common cold by as much as (on average) 1.4 days. If taken before the cold takes hold, echinacea may reduce the risk of catching a cold in the first place by as much as 58 percent [source: Paddock]. However, in 2010 a new study concluded that taking echinacea didn't improve the duration or symptoms of a cold any better than a placebo could; in fact, the most optimistic - yet statistically insignificant - outcome suggested it may reduce the length of a cold by about seven hours [source: Paddock]. So the jury's still out.
In addition to treating colds, some people also use echinacea to treat problems including typhoid, malaria, and genital herpes; there's no clinical evidence echinacea would be beneficial treating any such things.
9. Vitamin C Versus the Common Cold
Vitamin C, like echinacea, is one of the first supplements people turn to during cold season.
In 1970, scientist Linus Pauling believed the common cold could be controlled with vitamin C, aka L-ascorbic acid. He recommended doses of 3,000 milligrams of the vitamin supplement as the way to prevent catching a cold, and also, over time, to help completely wipe out the offending viruses.
But he was incorrect. Vitamin C is no more effective against an upper respiratory infection than a placebo is, concludes study after study. While one 2007 study found that yes, perhaps high doses of vitamin C - we're talking vitamin C megadoses of at least 200 mg per day (more than double the average recommended daily allowance for adults) - may ever-so-slightly reduce the length of your cold, it's only effective for a small number of people (about 8 percent of adults). If you must treat your cold with vitamin C, don't go overboard; more than 2,000 milligrams of vitamin C in a day can irritate your stomach and cause other problems, such as kidney stones. The exception: Marathon runners and other endurance athletes may find vitamin C supplements between 250 milligrams and 1 gram per day may reduce their risk of catching a cold by as much as 50 percent [source: NIH - ODS].
8. Zinc Versus the Common Cold
Some people swear by zinc for colds, and it may help, but scientific studies have been inconclusive.
If zinc lozenges and supplements are beneficial in waging war against the common cold, it might be because zinc is an antioxidant. It's also an anti-inflammatory, which may ease your cold symptoms. Or it could be that sucking on zinc lozenges may work because zinc is an anti-viral, literally stopping the cold virus from being able to spread in your mouth and throat. Or it may be that zinc doesn't have any scientific evidence to back up any of the anecdotal evidence. Studies are inconclusive, and only about half of those who've tried zinc report the mineral had any positive impact on the length of their cold or on reducing the severity of their cold symptoms [source: Cleveland Clinic].
Not all zinc supplements are created equal; some research indicates those made with zinc acetate or zinc gluconate, rather than with zinc glycinate or zinc citrate, are more likely to reduce the amount of time you suffer your cold symptoms [source: Prasad]. Timing is important, too. Even if you take the right type of zinc, if you're too late you won't have the benefits; if it's going to work, it'll only do so if you start treating your cold within the first 24 hours of your first symptoms.
Not only are zinc supplements an unreliable cold treatment, neither will they make your hair grow. While technically, yes, zinc can be used against hair loss, that's only in cases where your hair loss is due to a zinc deficiency. Treat the deficiency and your hair loss will stop. But if you don't have a zinc deficiency, increasing your zinc intake won't turn your limp locks luxurious.
7. Garlic Versus the Common Cold
Whether or not it will help your cold, garlic is delicious, so there’s that.
Garlic is a boost to any kitchen pantry, and outside your favourite dish it may also have some health benefit; it may help people get their blood pressure under control. Research suggests that garlic may ease hypertension. But if you're taking garlic supplements as a cold remedy, or for any other health benefit, you're probably out of luck.
Garlic contains a sulphur-containing compound called allicin, which may have both antibacterial and antiviral properties, and because of that the vegetable was adopted as potential way to prevent and treat against the hundreds of viruses that cause the common cold. Despite its popularity, though, there's little evidence that eating raw garlic, or taking supplements, can reduce the severity of your cold symptoms or the length of time you suffer your cold, culminating in a 2012 study that concluded more evidence is needed before anyone can claim with certainty garlic's role against rhinoviruses [source: Lissiman et al].
6. Vitamin D for Heart Health
There is some evidence that vitamin D supplements can help protect you against rickets, but they won’t
really contribute to heart health.
Sun exposure gives the biggest delivery of vitamin D to your body; as much as 80 to 90 percent of all your vitamin D intake happens this way [source: National Institutes of Health]. Supplementing your diet with vitamin D is a good way to prevent bone conditions such as rickets and osteomalacia, as well as to treat the skin condition psoriasis. But if you're taking vitamin D in an effort to reduce your risk of developing heart disease, don't bother. While studies indicate a person with higher levels of vitamin D circulating through his body has a lower risk of developing heart disease or having heart failure than a person with low levels of the vitamin, there's no conclusive evidence that supplementation in an effort to prevent heart failure or boost heart health makes any discernible difference in your health - and some studies have found vitamin D supplementation had a negative effect on the heart, the very opposite of what you want from your vitamins and minerals [source: National Institutes of Health, Mayo Clinic].
5. Yohimbe Bark as an Aphrodisiac
Yohimbe bark is sometimes used to make tea. As with most barks, it doesn’t look especially appetizing
in its natural state.
Yohimbe bark is most commonly taken because its active ingredient, yohimbine, is supposed to be an aphrodisiac. Yohimbe has been used in Africa in this way for hundreds of years, but there isn't any conclusive evidence suggesting the supplement works as a sexual stimulant. Yohimbe bark is actually considered unsafe in Germany because of its side effects, and the supplements available in the U.S. contain only small amounts (less than 7 percent) of the active ingredient [source: American Cancer Society].
What's interesting, though, is that some emerging evidence suggests that yohimbine may be effective in treating sexual dysfunction caused as a side effect of certain antidepressants, specifically selective-serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) such as the popular brand name antidepressants Prozac, Paxil and Zoloft. Additionally, there is a possibility that yohimbine may also help treat some types of erectile dysfunction (ED) - mild types caused by psychological rather than physical problems. In this regard, the American Urological Association is unconvinced of its efficacy and recommends further evaluation.
4. Chromium to Treat Type 2 Diabetes
Glucose testing is a routine part of life for many people with type 2 diabetes.
More than 8 percent of Americans have type 2 diabetes - that's just shy of 26 million people. Many of those people rely on blood sugar (glucose) testing and medications such as insulin, biguanides (including the brand name Metformin) and DPP-4 inhibitors (including brand name Januvia) to keep themselves healthy [source: NDEP]. What if you could improve your blood sugar levels - whether diagnosed with type 2 diabetes or not - with a mineral supplement, instead?
Chromium is a mineral your body uses to control its glucose levels. Because of this, it's easy to extrapolate that if you supplement your diet with chromium you'll prevent or control your diabetes. Marketing got something right, right? Well, maybe not right at all. Studies offer conflicting evidence about the effectiveness of chromium supplements to prevent or treat diabetes. For every report finding that chromium supplements do have a measurable positive impact on your glucose levels, another will find no benefit at all to the supplementation.
3. DHEA for Anti-aging
Products claiming to boost sex drive and slow aging are big business.
Dehydroepiandrosterone, known as DHEA, is a hormone your body naturally makes (your adrenal glands produce it). Specifically it's called a prohormone because your body needs it to activate the production of testosterone and estrogen. And because of its connection with our sex hormones, we hope taking supplements will, for example, boost our sex drive. But no study can validate that claim. DHEA supplements are marketed with the fountain of youth in mind; in addition to the improved sex drive claims, DHEA is also touted to slow down the aging process, build muscle and boost your immune system. But there's no evidence these supplements can do anything of the sort, either. Studies overwhelmingly find that taking DHEA supplements is no better than taking a placebo.
2. Fish Oil is Not a Panacea for Your Health Problems
Fish oil makes everything better! Not so fast. It’s good, but it’s not magic.
Americans spend a lot of money on fish oil purchases - more than US$1 billion per year on over-the-counter fish oil supplements (and that doesn't even count the jar of peanut butter plus omega-3 fatty acids you keep in your pantry) [source: LeWine].
Fish oil will probably not make any discernible impact on your child's intelligence, or protect against Crohn's disease or mental illness including major depression. Many of us take fish oil capsules believing the omega-3 fatty acids will reduce our risk of developing heart disease; while some studies suggest that fish oil supplements may have heart-healthy benefits, conflicting recent research finds its heart benefits may be bunk. Or at the very least, inconclusive or biased. Studies are finding that patients with cardiovascular disease do not have any reduction in their risk of having a(nother) heart attack, nor does fish oil lower their risk of stroke, congestive heart failure or any other cardiovascular condition after taking supplements for a minimum of one year.
While fish oil doesn't live up to the hype that surrounds it, it's also not a snake oil remedy - research shows promise that adding it to your diet helps protect against colorectal cancer. The best way to get your daily intake of fish oil isn't with supplements. Eat fish. (For you non-meat eaters, flax is a good substitute.)
1. Multivitamins May Not Have Any Benefits
Millions of people take daily multivitamins, but they may do just as well to skip them.
Nearly 40 percent of American adults take a daily multivitamin, and more than 50 percent of American adults take some sort of dietary supplement (the most popular is a daily calcium supplement) [source: Fetters]. While evidence suggests that calcium may actually have a positive impact on your health, there doesn't seem to be any evidence any other ingredient in your multivitamin does anything positive for you. At all. And in addition to that bombshell, some research suggests those of us who take vitamins may die sooner than our friends who skip the supplements. Yes, you read that correctly; in 2011 The Iowa Women's Health Study found multivitamins didn't offer any health benefits to the women taking them - and also found an association between taking dietary supplements and a shortened lifespan [source: Mursu]. It's entirely possible that this is due to people having a false sense of security about their health; taking a multivitamin may make them less likely to take care of themselves in other ways.
The best thing to do is ditch the daily vitamins and instead make sure you eat a healthy, balanced diet.
Author's Note: As a person who tries to remember to take her multivitamin (and maybe a few other supplements here and there), I was really curious what I'd find when I started looking into the pros and cons of dietary supplements. Should we bother taking them? Overwhelmingly the research for this article points to, well, maybe but maybe not - at least not a multivitamin. (Did you see that part about the shortened lifespan?) Unless you're taking a supplement because you have a legitimate deficiency, such as iron supplementation for iron-deficiency anaemia, you'd be best off with a healthy, balanced diet and exercise rather than a does-it-or-doesn't-it cure-all pill.
More Great Links:
1. National Institutes of Health - Office of Dietary Supplements: Vitamin and Mineral Supplement Fact Sheets
1. Allolio, B; and W Arlt. "DHEA treatment: myth or reality?" Trends in Endocrinology and Metabolism. Vol. 13, no. 7. Pages 288-294. September 2002. (May 31, 2014)
2. American Cancer Society. "Yohimbe." Nov. 28, 2008. (May 31, 2014)
3. American Diabetes Association (ADA). "Living With Diabetes: Oral Medications - What Are My Options?" Feb. 20, 2014. (May 31, 2014)
4. Bailey, Christoper H. "Improved Meta-Analytic Methods Show No Effect of Chromium Supplements on Fasting Glucose." Biological Trace Element Research. Vol. 157, no. 1. Pages 1-8. January 2014. (May 31, 2014)
5. Bankhead, Charles. "Fish Oil No Help for Secondary CVD Prevention." MedPage Today. April 9, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
6. Benaroch, Roy. "Vitamin C for the Common Cold." WebMD. June 20, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
7. Cartwright, Martina M. "The 'Cold' Facts About Zinc." Huffington Post. Dec. 12, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
8. Cleveland Clinic. "Garlic Supplement Review." (May 31, 2014)
9. Cleveland Clinic. "Zinc." (May 31, 2014)
10. Douglas, Robert M; and Harri Hemila. "Vitamin C for Preventing and Treating the Common Cold." PLOS Medicine. Vol. 2, no. 6. June 28, 2005. (May 31, 2014)
11. Eating Well. "Immune-Boosting Myths Busted." (May 31, 2014)
12. Ehrlich, Steven D. "Chromium." University of Maryland Medical Center. May 7, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
13. Fantar, Suzanne. "Does Chewing Garlic Help a Cold?" SFGate.com. (May 31, 2014)
14. Fetters, K. Aleisha. "Health myth: Do you really need to take a multivitamin?" Fox News. Feb. 20, 2014. (May 31, 2014)
15. Fiala, Thomas. "DHEA: Super Supplement Or Snake Oil?" FIALA Aesthetics. April 3, 2009. (May 31, 2014)
16. Gann, Carrie. "Fish Oil Delivers Few Heart Benefits, Study Finds." ABC News Medical Unit. April 9, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
17. Guallar, Eliseo; Stranges, Saverio; Mulrow, Cynthia; Appel, Lawrence; and Edgar Miller III. "Enough is Enough: Stop Wasting Money on Vitamin and Mineral Supplements." Annals of Internal Medicine. Col. 159, no. 12. Dec. 17, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
18. Kiefer, David. "Weight Loss & Diet Plans - DHEA Supplements." WebMD. Sept. 26, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
19. Kluber, Amy. "Are fish oil benefits a myth?" WPXI News. March 18,2 014. (May 31, 2014)
20. Landman, Gijs; Bilo, Henk; Houweling, Sebastiaan; and Nanne Kleefstra. "Chromium does not belong in the diabetes treatment arsenal: Current evidence and future perspectives." World Journal of Diabetes. Vol. 5, no. 2. Pages 160-164. April 15, 2014. (May 31, 2014)
21. Lev-Tzion, R; Griffiths, A; Ledder, O; and D Turner. "Omega 3 fatty acids (fish oil) for maintenance of remission in Crohn's disease." Cochrane Summaries. Feb. 28, 2014. (May 31, 2014)
22. LeWine, Howard. "Fish oil: friend or foe?" Harvard Health Blog - Harvard Medical School. July 12, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
23. Lissiman, Elizabeth; Bhasale, Alice L.; and Marc Cohen. "Garlic for the common cold." The Cochraine Library. March 14,2 012. (May 31, 2014)
24. Macknin, Michael L. "Zinc lozenges for the common cold." Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine. Vol. 66, no. 1. Pages 27-31. January 1999. (May 31, 2014)
25. Mahoney, Sarah. "Do Women Really Need Multivitamins?" Prevention. November 2011. (May 31, 2014)
26. Mayo Clinic. "Vitamin D." Nov. 1, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
27. Morrison, Deane. "Hold the supplements." University of Minnesota. Nov. 30, 2011. (May 31, 2014)
28. Mursu, Jaakko; Robien, Kim; Harnack, Lisa; Park, Kyong; and David R. Jacobs. "Dietary Supplements and Mortality Rate in Older Women: The Iowa Women's Health Study" JAMA Internal Medicine. Oct. 10, 2011. (May 31, 2014)
29. Nair, KS; Rizza, RA; O'Brien, P; Dhatariya, K; Short, KR; Nehra, A; Vittone, JL; Klee, GG; Basu, A; Cobelli, C; Toffolo, G; Dalla Man, C; Tindall DJ; Melton, LJ 3rd; Smith, GE; Khosla, S; and MD Jensen. "DHEA in elderly women and DHEA or testosterone in elderly men." New England Journal of Medicine. Vol. 355, no. 16. Pages 1647-1659. Oct. 19, 2006. (May 31, 2014)
30. National Institutes of Health - MedlinePlus. "Vitamin D." May 17, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
31. National Institutes of Health - National Diabetes Education Program (NDEP). "The Facts About Diabetes: A Leading Cause of Death in the U.S." (May 31, 2014)
32. National Institutes of Health - Office of Dietary Supplements. "Chromium." Nov. 4, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
33. National Institutes of Health - Office of Dietary Supplements. "Vitamin C." June 5, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
34. Nordqvist, Christian. "What is Echinacea? What Are The Benefits Of Echinacea." Medical News Today. Nov. 13, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
35. Offit, Paul. "The Vitamin Myth: Why We Think We Need Supplements." The Atlantic. July 19, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
36. Paddock, Catherine. "Echinacea Helps You Avoid And Recover From Colds Say Scientists." Medical News Today. June 25, 2007. (May 31, 2014)
37. Paddock, Catherine. "Echinacea No Big Impact On Common Cold." Medical News Today. Dec. 21, 2010. (May 31, 2014)
38. Park, Alice. "Fish Oil for Heart Attack Prevention: Is It a Myth?" Time. April 10, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
39. Parramore, Lynne Stuart. "Are vitamins a scam?" Salon. June 25, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
40. Pittas, AG; Chung, M; Trikalinos, T; Mitri, J; Brendel, M; Patel, K; Lichtenstein, AH; Lau, J; and EM Balk. "Systematic review: Vitamin D and cardiometabolic outcomes." Annals of Internal Medicine. Vol. 152, no. 5. Pages 307-314. March 2, 2010. (May 31, 2014)
41. Prasad, AS; Beck, FW; Bao, B; Snell, D; and JT Fitzgerald. "Duration and severity of symptoms and levels of plasma interleukin-1 receptor antagonist, soluble tumour necrosis factor receptor, and adhesion molecules in patients with common cold treated with zinc acetate." The Journal of Infectious Diseases. Vol. 197, no. 6. Pages 795-802. March 25, 2008. (May 31, 2014)
42. Ried, K; Frank, OR; Stocks, NP; Fakler, P; and T Sullivan. "Effect of garlic on blood pressure: a systematic review and meta-analysis." BMC Cardiovascular Disorders. Vol. 8, no. 13. June 16, 2008. (May 31, 2014)
43. Reinberg, Steven. "Why Do Millions of Americans Take Multivitamins?" WebMD. (May 31, 2014)
44. Risk and Prevention Study Collaborative Group. "n-3 Fatty Acids in Patients with Multiple Cardiovascular Risk Factors." The New England Journal of Medicine. Vol. 368. Pages 1800-1808. May 9, 2013. (May 31, 2014)
45. Sample, Ian. "Cold comfort: vitamin C myth exposed." The Guardian. July 18, 2007. (May 31, 2014)
46. Schmidt, PJ; Daly, RC; Bloch, M; Smith, MJ; Danaceau, MA; St. Clair, LS; Murphy, JH; Hag, N; and DR Rubinow. "Dehydroepiandrosterone monotherapy in midlife-onset major and minor depression." Archives of General Psychiatry. Vol. 62, no. 2. Pages 154-162. February 2005. (May 31, 2014)
47. Scott, Paula Spencer. "Colds and Flu: Myths vs. Facts." Arthritis Foundation. (May 31, 2014)
48. Suksomboon, N.; Poolsup, N.; and A. Yuwanakorn. "Systematic review and meta-analysis of the efficacy and safety of chromium supplementation in diabetes.." Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics. Vol. 39, no. 3. Pages 292-306. March 17, 2014. (May 31, 2014)
49. University of Maryland Medical Centre. "Echinacea." May 7, 2013.(May 31, 2014)
50. Walsh, Trainor. "Annual CRN Consumer Survey Finds Overall Use of Supplements on the Rise." Council for Responsible Nutrition. March 13, 2012. (May 31, 2014)
51. WebMD. "Echinacea." (May 31, 2014)
52. WebMD. "Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database: Yohimbe." (May 31, 2014)
53. Weiss, Jean. "Vitamin Myths, Truths and Tips." MSN Health & Fitness. (May 31, 2014)
Top image via FiT Sports Lab.
[Source: How Stuff Works. Edited. Top image added.]